10-30-2013: Obamacare Reality and The Free Market Lie

Posted: October 30, 2013 in Constitution Watch
Tags: ,

Let’s consider an obvious question.  If Americans desire a product such as health insurance as much as big government Comrades parrot daily; why would our liberty loving Comrades require a Federal law forcing those Americans to buy it?   Regardless the insidious end run of our political hack judicial branch, the Supreme Circus around the Constitutional legality; this is precisely what the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA), aka ACA, aka Obamacare, does.  It FORCES and FORCE isn’t freedom.

Factually, as a minimum, we know the following mandates will each contribute to higher cost in providing healthcare coverage, which in turn will increase premiums.
Mandate 1.  A child can remain on the family policy until age 26.
Mandate 2.  Elimination of pre-existing condition clauses.  Insurers must cover every person no matter what.
Mandate 3.  As of January 1, 2014, all annual limits on essential health benefits are banned.

We also know that as of today in 2013, our Federal government does not permit health insurance to be sold across state lines.  In other words, our Federal government has established intrastate health insurance monopolies within each state and those monopolies are protected by regulatory agencies at the expense of the tax paying consumer.  Granted, these are not true monopolies by a single provider within each state; but are highly regulated monopolies none-the-less, heavily restricting open competition among providers for customers within each State market.

The current system provides the allusion of open competition, while guaranteeing there is very little.  One positive note within this government restricted market is that even with these monopolies in place, we still have thousands of plan choices across the country.  There are choices within each State in spite of intrastate monopoly.

Under PPACA as best I understand it, there are only four plans to choose from.  Pick or die basically and Comrades apparently are oblivious to what it costs, not to mention that you will be insanely fined if your plan is better than any of these four.  Is your household budget oblivious to product cost?  Mine isn’t.  What does level of coverage matter, if we can’t afford the premiums anyway?  If government forced health care premiums rise to 25% or more of my household budget;  my house is in financial difficulty and part time work doesn’t fix it.

Further, according to the Centers For Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) data, a total of $2.7 trillion (17.9% of GDP) was spent on U.S. health care in 2011.  Of this $2.7 trillion, 21% or $554.3 billion went to Medicare; and 15% or $407.7 billion went to MedicaidOut-of-pocket expenses totaled $307.7 billion (11%) for 2011 and the balance of the $2.7 trillion total, the lion’s share, $1.4 trillion (53%) was picked up by the government sanctioned private health insurance monopolies.

Most, if not all of us agree with our Comrades that the above three mandates are in fact great, wonderful even – up until we notice the true cost of providing those coverages, at which point the whole discussion is moot for most of us.  We can’t get blood out of a turnip regardless how hard we squeeze.  The corrupt, government sanctioned intrastate monopolies – not so great on any level unless you’re on the corrupt receiving end of the monopoly cash flow.  Our existing system is insider corrupted and thoroughly broken – I’m certainly not saying it isn’t, though more government involvement is certainly not the solution.

Let’s work backwards.

Many say free markets have failed American health care.  Most who claim this are advocates of big government and collectivism.
1600 Watch claims the obvious fact as established by 2011 CMS data, that 36% of all U.S. health care costs are carried directly by government through Medicare and Medicaid.  The 53% private health insurance portion is under the central planning control of the Federal government established intrastate monopolies; or as some might call it – government protected PRICE FIXING – but I’m behaving this afternoon, so I don’t call it that.

In other words, 36% plus 53%, which totals 89% of all U.S. health care costs in 2011 involved Federal government control either directly or indirectly.  Only a seriously retarded victim of public school conditioning, robbed of their once bright future can call this a free market with a straight face.

THERE ARE NO FREE MARKETS IN U.S. HEALTH CARE INSURANCE IN 2013. PERIOD as Obama would say.  Having said that, we are starting to see some successful inroads in direct medical services or concierge plans being provided by Doc’s and clinics.  These are typically family medicine or primary care physicians providing basic services for a monthly fee.  The patient or subscriber then carries catastrophic coverage for the serious stuff.  These services are free markets in action and I’m sure the Obama Administration will soon attempt to make them illegal.

So much for the free market tall tale.  Facts speak otherwise or as Uncle Si might say, “That’s the facts, Jack”.

Given that 10,000 people per day are turning 60 years of age in the U.S.; and given more than 90% of all health care costs are typically  incurred in the last decade of life; there is nothing in sight suggesting average annual, U.S. health care expenditures will decline any time soon .

Working backwards  a bit more.  All three Federal Mandates identified above clearly cause provider liability to increase.  Insurance providers cover their costs through premium (and sometimes other investment) revenue, therefore the mandates obviously impact premiums upward.  There are no known PPACA mandates that work to reduce provider cost; so nothing in sight to reduce premiums.  Yet, in the face of these facts,  the Obama Administration has stridently told the American people that PPACA will lower the average family’s premiums by $2,500 per year.  I don’t consider Obama or any of the dozens of academic nincompoops in his West Wing ding bat cage to be sharp tools; but this is not a mistake.  THIS IS A LIE. PERIOD, as Obama would say.  Premiums are not going down as a result of Obamacare.

Another factoid.  We now know that Obama, his West Wing nincompoops and most Senators and Congressman knew three years ago (July, 2010), that up to 67% of existing health insurance policies would be liable to cancellation.  The only way any policy can be GRANDFATHERED is if the policy has not been modified in any way.  Therefore the ad nausea pronunciations by Obama and his parrots disingenuously stating “you can keep your insurance plan if you like it” is actually an INTENTIONAL BALD FACED DECEIT.

Marxist Muslim Obama, his Marxist Left Democrats and the Establishment Right GOP RINO’s  may all think this Obamacide debate is an academic D.C. exercise and great sport over twenty year old single malt – but it sure ain’t no freaking joke out here on Main Street.  Personally, my family hasn’t had health insurance for more than fifteen years due to preexisting conditions.  Health insurers puke at the sight of my family.  Five years ago, our civil engineering consulting business croaked, my wife got an office management job and health insurance coverage for herself.  We could not afford to add me onto the policy.  Several months ago, my several part time endeavors bumped our income sufficiently to add me to the policy.  Now we learned last week that our policy premium, with $5,000 deductibles for both my wife and  I ($10,000 together) are going up 48% on January 1st, 2014, but will likely be dropped altogether in March of 2014.  It now looks like I will have my own personal story about cancellation of the policy I liked and had for the first time in more than a decade and a half.

My parting swing here regards the potential damage of delaying any of these mandates, particularly the deferment waivers granted to employers and unions.

More than 160 million American employees receive health care coverage through employer group plans.  Obama, his Commie Democrats and the Establishment Right RINO’s are all on board with these waivers as a good thing, but they’re not a good thing at all.  First of all, any delay prolongs the uncertainty under which providers must function and small business owners must labor, survive and try to create jobs.  This alone is and will continue to have terrible economic consequences.

Secondly, Obama and his cronies never compromise.  They have no need to negotiate as the Establishment Right with crumbs like McConnell, McCain, Cornyn and others, roll over to have their bellies rubbed by the Progressive press corpse at every opportunity.  The only reason these corrupt miscreants agreed to waiving the employee mandate until 2015 is that if they pushed it now, the 16 million individuals now losing their existing coverage (84%) could grow by another 135 million Americans losing their employer provided coverage.  Eliminating these waivers would potentially lead to more than 150,000,000 Americans being kicked out of their existing health care coverage and the angst we see today would be like a preschool argument during recess compared to the social volcano that would ignite.  These profligate liars all understood that, but we the people apparently didn’t.  And then, finally, we don’t want voters to experience reality prior to the 2014 mid-term elections do we?

The astonishing extent to which both elected Representatives and appointed officials have misrepresented PPACA to the American people over the past three years constitutes the intentional abandonment of fiduciary responsibility to the American tax payer and a staggering betrayal of the public trust underlying our Republic.  I believe this deceit and financial malfeasance rises to the level of high crimes and misdemeanors for every elected Representative and appointed official who propagated this monstrous deceit; this abysmal failure to protect and defend our Constitution; and the intentional decision not to properly serve the best interest of the American people.

The United States has truly arrived at its pinnacle of embarrassed disgrace and is now the largest, most expensive banana republic yet seen in world history – and we the people voted for it – or at least the enormous government dependent patronage vote did.  I hope and pray we have the mental acuity and will to fix this incredible mess we have voted ourselves into.

I haven’t bothered to mention it, but the rationing committee, since renamed and passed as part of the Stimulus Bill preceding Obamacare passage is real and is in fact the only cost containment method incorporated into PPACA under what is called by the horrific euphemism, The Complete Lives System.

Solution Recommendation footnote:
Repeal PPACA immediately.  It cannot be fixed and is a stepping stone to centrally planned, single payer, rationed, government dependency.

Pass legislation containing one sentence, stating “health care insurance coverage is INTERSTATE commerce”.  This legislation costs nothing and will destroy the obscene intrastate monopolies our corrupt legislators have constructed with the lobbyists.  The insurance carriers are guilty, but so is the elected slime enabling the insurance sewer our money is flowing into.  Enable competition for God’s sake.  Is that so hard?

Here’s my socialist solution if we must have one though I don’t care much for it:
Outside the young and/or wealthy who don’t want insurance or who are wealthy enough to buy their own, there are approximately 15,000,000 uninsured folks who would like to have health insurance and absolutely cannot get it.  Leave our health care system and Doc’s alone; create a Federal dependency fund run by each State, basically Medicaid without State matching funds, paying out $400 per month toward premiums to each of the 15 million or so qualified beneficiaries at an annual cost under $80 billion {15,000,000 x $400 x 12 = $72,000,000,000).  Simple and clean while the above recommendation kicks in and starts providing a competitive cost structure with real plans real people can really aff0rd so we can eventually get rid of the socialist fix and be real Americans again.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s